top of page
Stacked Hardcover Books

Preparing a PhD Proposal

Within 6 months following enrolment, the PhD student is expected to complete a proposal, which will be reviewed by a confirmation panel composed of the Head of the School of Law, Politics, and Philosophy and the Division of Arts, Law, Psychology, and Social Science's Associate Dean Postgraduate. The following is a guide for my students to use in preparing the PhD proposal. ​

​

What is the PhD proposal? The PhD thesis/dissertation research proposal is an overview of a multi-year project that the postgraduate anticipates completing in a three-year period. It serves not just as a summary of the thesis, which it necessarily must do, but also will explain to the confirmation panel how the student intends to complete the project. More on this later.

​

What happens after the proposal is completed? Once the supervisory team is satisfied with the student's proposal, it will be finalised and sent to the confirmation panel. A meeting will be scheduled, and the student will present the material to the panel. Panelists and the supervisory team will have an opportunity to ask the candidate questions of the project. 

​​

How should the student think about the proposal? The thesis proposal shouldn't be overly ambitious. Undergraduate essays, and perhaps even your Master's thesis or Bachelor's honours thesis addressed a BIG question that was broadly construed. Don't do that in a PhD proposal because you want it to show that you will become the foremost expert on a very narrow topic.

​

The proposal should leave the confirmation panel with the impression that the thesis may be completed in the time allocated, usually three years by New Zealand standards. One of the greatest dangers graduate students face is coming up with a project that cannot be completed in a reasonable amount of time. The student shouldn't think of the PhD thesis as their final word on the subject matter.  In a sense, the thesis is their inaugural item permitting them entrance to the professional world.

 

What distinguishes my proposal from others' proposals? It should be original! Your conclusion should be novel, and it should show that you have thought carefully about the topic.

 

Second, an expectation of any PhD thesis is that it is an original and interesting contribution to the field.  Just as was mentioned above, we can think of the thesis as signalling the student's entrance to the professional field.  Because of that, the work should suggest that the thesis says something new and interesting in contrast with other works that have been published by professional colleagues. 

​

So, what about the mechanics of the research proposal?  The University has published regulations on what it would like to see in a full research proposal, and they are published here. I presume that you're familiar with the guide; I also presume that the research plan you submit to me is consistent with the requirements of the University.  Note, however, that my standards are more strict than the University's and that you'll be expected to satisfy my requirements before confirmation of enrolment may be awarded.

​

The research proposal should summarise your thesis' main argument, and it should outline each of the auxiliary arguments that support the main argument.  Of course, the auxiliary and main argument, as outlined in the proposal may be flawed. What supervisors are to do is help you work through these flaws in the preliminary stages of the writing to ensure that none of the flaws of the arguments end up in the final product.  Expect to have about 10-15 pages of text on the main and auxiliary arguments of the thesis.

​

The proposal should defend reasons for thinking that your contribution to the field is original.  In New Zealand, folks call this the "literature review."  I take that title to be ambiguous because under such an aegis one could just go and give a cursory summary of what has been written.  That's not a literature review; that's plagiarism.  In the proposal, tell your supervisory panel why your work is distinctive. Ask yourself what sets your work apart from others? And argue for your view, suggesting that there's no one out there other than you who will be an expert in this one particular and narrowly conceived field.

​

Your proposal should include a bibliography.  The length of it is up to you, but you should realise that I will ask in a formal setting why you've included a reading and what the main argument of that reading is.  So expect to defend your reasons for including it in the proposal.  

bottom of page